Module I

Garrett DeWeese

Solving the problem of evil

Evil is not a disproof of God. The logical problem has an answer. The evidential and existential problems need the cross, not a shrug.

Take with you

  • The logical problem: God and evil can both exist if God has good reasons (a defense, not always a theodicy).
  • Free-will and soul-making accounts are not cute. They name the kind of world in which love is possible.
  • The evidential problem asks ‘too much evil.’ We are not in a position to see the whole ledger.
  • The existential problem is a person in pain. Lead with presence. Then point to a God who did not stay out of it.

Say this

If there is no God, evil is just what happens. Our outrage only makes sense if the law is real. I do not pretend to have every reason. I do know that God did not stay away from the worst of it.

Questions